I needed to talk to someone. Without delay. Katalin and Chandler were both out of the question, and Thom and Jerry had class.
By now it was 11AM, and I had finished English and Psychology, leaving me free until History at 2:30. I knew Ashley didn't have class until after lunch, so I headed for E Tower.
Ashley had switched roommates within a week of me. She had originally roomed with a girl named Gwen. They were both nice people, but Ashley tended toward more conventional behavior while...ah, hell. I'll just go out and say it: Gwen was a party girl, Ashley wasn't. Most of the girls on the floor thought Gwen was easy and rejected her for it. Gwen told me she was a "kissing slut," but swore she didn't sleep around. She wasn't my type, so I took her word for it and left the issue alone.
What this switch meant was that Morgan was now Ashley's roommate. Word had reached me that Morgan was the only one in the tower who'd wanted me to leave instead of William (I had decided it was easier to bite the bullet and move than put up with the drama he'd be sure to kick up at the prospect of getting his ass out of the tower). Apparently Prince William had been unsuccessfully trying to take liberties with the ladies and was quickly wearing his welcome thin.
Morgan was the only classical beauty in the pod, but finished well short of the other girls on self-esteem and general friendliness. She had a tendency to solicit unwelcome advice and to steer any conversation in her direction. To her credit, she made an effort to be nicer to me after she found out how I felt about her. Like most people I've met, I wouldn't classify her as necessarily a bad person, just different from me.
Really, my biggest single complaint about Morgan was that she and William attracted each other like opposing magnetic polls. She was his version of Katalin, I suppose.
The trouble was that when I poked my head in the door, William and Morgan both present in addition to Ashley. There were three people in the world I didn't want in on this conversation, and William was one of them (the other two being Chandler and Vanilla Ice, just because I fucking hate Vanilla Ice).
"Hi, Ashley." I said. "Morgan, William."
Ashely smiled and returned the greeting. Morgan said "hi," absent mindedly. William didn't acknowledge my presence.
"What's up, Mark?" asked Ashley.
"Nothing much. Just looking for somebody to talk to. You're not busy, are you?"
"No, no, I'm clear." she glanced over her desk to where Morgan and William were still enveloped in whatever conversation they were having. "Want to go to lunch?"
"Sure." I said.
"Oh, where are you going?" threw in William.
"Brooks." I said.
"Oh, get us a table, we'll catch up to you!"
"Okay, see you there." I said, faking enthusiasm.
"McKinley's it is." I said once Ashley and I had passed the fire doors.
Ashely giggled. "Sounds good to me."
"So, how goes the new living arrangements?"
"Better." she said. "Morgan and I have issues, but it's nothing like Gwen and I did. How about you?"
"Eh, Jamie watches a lot of TV. That's my biggest complaint, so you know there's nothing bad going on."
We continued with the small talk. Ashley judiciously avoided commenting on the proverbial elephant-in-the-room I had on a leash behind me.
We were early for lunch, and so managed to get our food quickly before parking ourselves in the back booth--the same one I'd sat with Chandler in on election night. It seemed like a year ago now, and it hadn't even been a month.
I explained my revelation to Ashley, leaving the issue with Katalin out entirely. After all, I had made a promise.
"Wow. That's pretty deep." she said. "I'd have thought you'd bring something like to Katalin, or somebody like that." I cursed myself for being so predictable. "Um, Mark? I'm curious, and feel free to not answer if you don't want to, but...well, is there something going on between you and Katalin?"
The question was made with pure sincerity and honest curiosity, thus proving that God not only has a sense of humor, but also a sense of irony.
"We're not an item, if that's what you're getting at." We both knew damn well she was.
"Oh. Sorry." I assumed she was apologizing for asking, not for me being together with Katalin.
Perhaps I should go back a little bit with Ashley's and my relationship. She'd had a steady boyfriend, Walter, since high school. She was a transfer student, a sophomore (which shows you the level of commitment between the two of them). Every couple of weekends, one of them would go visit the other; he was at Penn State, three hours away. Every sign I could read said it was the real thing between the two of them.
Ashley (and apparently Walt as well, though I'd only met him once and then only briefly) had a warped sense of humor like mine. I liked her a lot, but not in the romantic sense--as I've said, I tend to not form that sort of relationship with someone who makes it clear from beginning she's not available.
One thing happened that makes me wonder, though. It was in the interval between William and I declaring war and my moving out. I was watching TV in the D Lounge around midnight. She came in from outside.
I don't recall the details exactly, but I made some crack about watching a dirty movie. She opened her jacket--not her shirt, her jacket--grinned, and said, "I can be dirty, if you want."
I feigned horror. "Think of Walt!"
She giggled and went up to her room. Now, I'm 99% certain she was joking around, (God knows I was) but the look in her eyes just keeps that last shadow of a doubt from vanishing.
"It's okay." I said. "I'm just not sure what to do about Chandler. At this point, I don't know if I even want to fix things."
"But...he's your friend."
"I thought he was. Ashley, I have this tendency to flesh in details about people I don't know with what I'd like those details to be. I think that's what I did here. The way Chandler carries himself made me like him, just like most of us fell for William early on. I noticed some similarities between the two of them early on, before I started hating William. I pushed them to the back of my mind later, dismissed Chandler as different.
"Now I think that Chandler and William weren't so different, after all. They're both manipulators, it's just that Chandler was better at it, harder to catch."
"Chandler seemed like a nice guy, if you ask me." said Ashley.
I cradled my head in my forehead. Too much thought and not enough sleep were giving me a nasty headache. "That just proves my point. And yes, I'm aware that's circular logic. Just give me a moment to collect myself and I'll address that."
I took a deep breath. "Okay, I'll try to avoid demonizing Chandler and William or canonizing myself, but no promises.
"Remember at the start of the year, how everyone was kind of self-conscious and awkward?"
"Yeah, that happens when everyone's new."
"Right, but remember William? He seemed a lot more at ease than everyone else, remember?"
She paused for a moment. "Yeah, he did seem a little more confident than anyone else, especially among the freshmen."
I sighed. "He wasn't. Out in the open, he was infallible. But back in the dorm room, he would stress out over every little thing. His clothes, his hair, the music he was playing when the door was open--"
"I bet your music wasn't a hit with him." said Ashley. She knew that'd I'd had a habit of playing "Supernova Goes Pop" by Powerman 5000 at full volume just to annoy William (it's an uninteresting metal song with a lot of loud, heavy guitars. It could drown out Keane at half volume). I couldn't help but smile at the memory.
"More than once, I had to ask him to put headphones on because of that donging noise Instant Messenger makes when it's receiving. We'd only been there a week, so I doubt he was being barraged with conversations from fellow Alleghenians. I think he was doing the same thing I--and I assume most of the other freshmen--was doing: IMing his friends back home for support."
Ashley coughed. It took me a moment to figure out what she was getting at.
"Yes, transfers, too. Happy?"
She nodded.
"So anyway, he put up this confident facade, but for what?"
"I assume you're going to tell me."
"I'm going to have to shift gears for a second. Answer this honestly, because if I figured this wrong, the whole argument kind of falls apart.
"Of me and William, who did you like first?"
Ashley hesitated for a few seconds, then hazarded an answer. "To be honest? William."
"And which one of us you still like is obvious enough, considering you had no qualms with ditching one of us to be with the other."
"So that has something to do with William pretending to be confident, huh? Look, Mark, confidence isn't a guarantee people are going to like you."
"It doesn't have to be. This is where it all comes together. The reason you liked me is because I presented myself as being your equal and waited for you decide whether or not you enjoyed my company, which you eventually did. You made that decision for yourself, and neither my attitude nor yours has changed significantly since then, so your decision still stands.
"William, on the other hand, used that aura of confidence to push himself up the totem pole, meaning he could present himself as your superior. He seemed like he knew what he was doing, and parlayed that confidence into authority. Rather than wait for you to decide whether or not you like him, he used that authority to tell you that you liked him. As time passed, everyone else caught up to William in confidence, making everyone an equal again. Once you were equals, your attitude changed, so you reassessed your feelings toward William, this time deciding that you disliked him."
Ashley just looked at me. After a few seconds, she said, "And psychology isn't your major because..."
"Well, mostly because I didn't hear a word of today's lecture while I was thinking that whole thing up."
That got the laugh I was looking for. What I didn't tell Ashley was how I knew so much about manipulation. I'd been a manipulator myself in high school. At first it was fun, learning how to make people do what I wanted; sometime I was even able to convince them they enjoyed doing it.
What wound up breaking me of the habit was failure. The one person I wanted to play into my hands had been oddly immune to everything I tried. Finally, I gave up on what I now consider immoral behavior. It was toward the end of my junior year; shortly after, she started to flirt back. By now you should know who I'm talking about.
"But what about Chandler?" Ashley asked.
"He was the same way. Slick, smooth. Acted like he knew everything he was doing. It was the same deal. He just happened to be gifted with a more engaging personality than William, so he was harder to see through."
"So, what are you going to do?"
"I...I'm not sure. I mean, I thought Chandler was my friend, but now I'm worried I might have just been his pawn."
"You're overthinking it." The voice wasn't Ashley's. In fact, I knew exactly whose it was. "And frankly, I find it insulting that you're not only talking about me behind my back, but you're doing it in my favorite booth when you know I always each lunch around about now."
"Ashley, perhaps you'd better go." I said. She nodded and left. "Chandler, how long have you been listening?"
"Around about the time you said that Katalin was shutting you out." So, he was in a combative mood. Then again, who wouldn't be by now? I cursed myself for sitting with my back to the foodcourt.
"Well, you might as well sit down in this booth, we've got a lot to talk about." I said.
"Agreed."
Originally posted on January 12th, 2005